Upgrade and Maintenance of Roller Shutter Doors - Edinburgh and Oban

This tender provides clear service requirements and utilizes an e-procurement portal, but suffers from significant transparency issues due to missing evaluation criteria and explicit mandatory exclusion grounds.

The tender defines the procedure type and CPV codes correctly. However, the absence of an explicit reveal date makes it impossible to verify compliance with minimum notice periods, and the lack of explicit mandatory exclusion grounds is a notable legal deficiency in the provided information.

The description of the required services and technical requirements is clear and unambiguous. However, the complete absence of specified evaluation criteria significantly hinders bidders' understanding of how their proposals will be assessed, which is a major clarity concern.

Basic information, financial details, and timeline are largely complete. However, the critical omission of evaluation criteria and the limited content provided for the tender documents (with the main PDF marked 'Required: No') indicate significant gaps in the completeness of the directly accessible tender information.

The tender discloses the estimated value and uses an e-procurement portal, promoting equal access. However, the complete lack of evaluation criteria severely compromises fairness and transparency, as bidders cannot objectively prepare or understand the basis of award. The missing reveal date also impacts the ability to confirm fair preparation time.

The tender scores well on practicality, supporting electronic submission via the Delta eSourcing portal, providing clear URLs, and specifying the contract start date and duration. Financing information (estimated value) is also available.

Most key fields are populated, and dates are logical and consistent. There are no reported disputes or suspensions. Minor inconsistencies include an empty 'Liable Person' field and 'N/A' codes for procedure type, but these do not significantly impact overall data integrity.

The tender does not include any explicit green procurement, social aspects, or innovation focus. It is also not indicated as EU funded, which often correlates with higher sustainability standards.