Medical staff Manual Handling

This tender suffers from critical deficiencies, primarily the inclusion of incorrect and unrelated tender documents, which severely compromises its legal compliance, completeness, clarity, and fairness. While basic information is present and e-procurement is enabled, the fundamental issue with documentation makes it highly problematic.

The most significant issue is the inclusion of completely unrelated documents (Glasgow City Council industrial refurbishment) as part of the tender documentation for 'Medical staff Manual Handling'. This is a severe breach of mandatory disclosure requirements. The missing reveal date also prevents a full assessment of the reasonableness of the submission period.

While the AI-extracted requirements are clear and well-structured, the absence of specified evaluation criteria is a major clarity flaw. Furthermore, the presence of incorrect tender documents fundamentally obscures the actual requirements and scope of this specific tender.

The tender is critically incomplete due to the provision of irrelevant documents instead of the actual tender documentation. This means essential details for bidders are missing. The absence of evaluation criteria further reduces completeness.

Fairness is severely undermined by the lack of access to the correct tender documents and the absence of specified, objective evaluation criteria. Bidders cannot adequately prepare or understand the basis of assessment, creating an uneven playing field.

Electronic submission via Public Contracts Scotland is a positive aspect. However, the fundamental issue of incorrect tender documents makes it practically impossible for bidders to prepare a compliant and relevant proposal. The contract start date is also not specified.

The inclusion of documents pertaining to a completely different tender (Glasgow City Council refurbishment) under 'Tender Documents' for the University of Dundee's 'Medical staff Manual Handling' is a catastrophic data inconsistency. Minor inconsistencies include empty 'Liable Person' and 'N/A' codes.

The tender does not include any explicit green procurement, social aspects, or innovation focus. It is also not EU funded, which often correlates with higher sustainability standards.