Surface treatment works on state roads in Ida-Viru, Lääne-Viru and Järva counties in 2026

This tender demonstrates high quality in terms of clarity, fairness, and legal compliance, with well-defined evaluation criteria and ample preparation time. Key areas for improvement include explicitly stating contract duration and enhancing social and innovation aspects.

The tender exhibits strong legal compliance, with a reasonable period between reveal and submission (48 days), clear CPV codes, and no reported disputes. The use of the European Single Procurement Document (ESPD) and adherence to e-procurement procedures indicate alignment with EU/national regulations.

Clarity is excellent; the tender description is unambiguous, and requirements are well-documented. Crucially, evaluation criteria are explicitly stated as 'lowest price' in Document 16 and the AI-extracted financial requirements, directly addressing and correcting the automated check's 'Missing evaluation criteria' flag.

While most essential information is present, a notable gap is the lack of an explicit contract start date and precise duration. 'Tender Valid: 4 months' refers to the offer's validity, not the contract's. The NUTS code is also missing, though specific counties are named.

Fairness is very high, with full document access, disclosed value, and a generous 48-day preparation period. The 'lowest price' evaluation criterion is objective, and e-procurement ensures equal access. Requirements appear generic and not tailored, further enhanced by the division into parts for different counties.

Electronic submission is well-supported. However, the absence of a clear contract start date and precise duration poses a practical challenge for bidders in planning resources and commitments. While the contracts are for '2026', specific dates are not provided.

Data consistency is strong, with key fields largely populated and logical dates. There are no reported suspensions or disputes. The only minor inconsistency is the missing NUTS code.

The tender explicitly includes 'Green Procurement' characteristics, which is a positive aspect. However, it lacks specific criteria or focus on social aspects or innovation, which are integral components of comprehensive sustainability.