Legal Compliance60/100
The tender misclassifies the DPS as a "Restricted procedure" and fails to disclose mandatory information such as exclusion grounds, eligibility, financial requirements, and evaluation criteria in the public notice. The reveal date is also missing.
•Misclassification of procedure type (DPS as Restricted)
•Mandatory exclusion, eligibility, financial, and evaluation criteria not disclosed in public notice
Clarity55/100
While the overall purpose and lot structure are clear, the actual detailed requirements, selection criteria, and evaluation methodology are not specified in the public notice, requiring bidders to request an application pack.
•Detailed requirements and criteria not specified in the public notice
•Evaluation criteria are missing from the public notice
Completeness40/100
The tender is incomplete as the full application pack, containing essential details like mandatory requirements and evaluation criteria, is not directly attached or accessible via URL. The liable person is also missing.
•Full application pack not directly accessible/attached
•Mandatory requirements and evaluation criteria missing from public notice
Fairness50/100
Fairness is compromised by the requirement to email for the application pack, creating an unnecessary barrier to access. The absence of evaluation criteria in the public notice and lack of e-submission also reduce transparency and equal access.
•No direct document access (email request required)
•Evaluation criteria not specified in public notice
Practicality45/100
The tender lacks a direct document URL and clear support for electronic submission, requiring an email request for the application pack which adds an extra step for potential bidders.
•No direct document URL provided
•No clear electronic submission support
Data Consistency60/100
There is a significant inconsistency in classifying the DPS as a "Restricted procedure" when its description clearly outlines an open-ended system. The "Liable Person" field is also unpopulated.
•Inconsistent procedure type (Restricted vs. DPS description)
•Missing 'Liable Person' field
Sustainability75/100
The tender has a strong inherent focus on environmental sustainability and innovation, aligning with ESC's mission to decarbonise the UK energy system and promote clean growth. However, explicit social criteria are not mentioned.
•No explicit social criteria mentioned