Crombie Avenue Play Area

This tender for the Crombie Avenue Play Area provides basic information clearly but suffers from significant deficiencies in detailed legal compliance, clarity, and completeness, particularly regarding evaluation criteria and mandatory exclusion grounds. The absence of e-submission and sustainability considerations are also notable drawbacks.

Legal compliance is moderate due to the absence of specific mandatory exclusion grounds and detailed evaluation criteria beyond a high-level '100% quality' statement. While the procedure type and CPV codes are correctly assigned, these omissions reduce transparency and adherence to best practices.

The project description is clear and unambiguous. However, the clarity for bidders is significantly reduced by the lack of detailed evaluation criteria, the absence of specific mandatory exclusion grounds, and the lack of specific financial requirements.

Most basic information, including title, reference, organization, value, duration, and location, is provided. However, the tender is incomplete due to the lack of detailed evaluation criteria, specific mandatory exclusion grounds, financial requirements, and details on how the tender is 'Divided into Parts'.

Fairness is significantly impacted by the absence of an e-submission option, which hinders equal access for all potential bidders. Furthermore, the highly subjective '100% quality' evaluation criterion, without further objective breakdown, raises concerns about transparency and potential for subjective assessment.

Practicality is low due to the explicit lack of e-submission, which is a significant drawback in modern procurement. The absence of a direct document URL also adds a minor inconvenience for accessing tender documents.

Data consistency is generally good, with all key fields populated and no disputes or suspensions. A minor inconsistency exists between the estimated value stated in EUR and the equivalent GBP value mentioned in the document summary.

The tender completely lacks any mention of green procurement, social aspects, or innovation focus. This represents a significant missed opportunity to integrate modern sustainability and social value considerations into the procurement process.