Legal Compliance75/100
The tender clearly references the Utilities Contracts (Scotland) Regulations 2016 and specifies the procedure type and CPV codes. The absence of a 'reveal date' is a minor administrative detail for a DPS, which is continuously open.
•Missing reveal date (minor for DPS)
Clarity50/100
While the overall purpose of the DPS is clear, the tender lacks specific, detailed requirements beyond mandatory exclusion grounds and completely omits evaluation criteria, making it difficult for bidders to understand how they will be assessed.
•No evaluation criteria specified
•Minimal detailed requirements
Completeness60/100
Basic tender information, financial details, and duration are provided. However, the critical absence of detailed requirements and evaluation criteria makes the tender documentation incomplete for comprehensive application preparation.
•Missing detailed requirements
•No evaluation criteria specified
Fairness65/100
The disclosed value and long application period for the DPS are positive for fairness. However, the lack of transparent evaluation criteria and the absence of e-submission capabilities pose significant risks to objective assessment and equal access.
•No evaluation criteria specified
•No e-submission
Practicality60/100
The tender specifies duration but lacks an explicit document URL and does not support electronic submission, which reduces its practicality for potential applicants.
•No e-submission
•No explicit document URL
Data Consistency85/100
Key fields such as title, reference, organization, value, deadline, duration, CPV, and NUTS code are consistently populated. Minor omissions like 'Liable Person' and N/A codes do not significantly impact overall consistency.
•Liable Person not specified
•Type/Procedure codes N/A
Sustainability20/100
The tender does not include any explicit green procurement, social, or innovation criteria, indicating a lack of focus on broader sustainability objectives.
•No green procurement
•No social criteria